December 11, 2001
Robert
Scheer:
Connect the Enron Dots to Bush
Enron is Whitewater in spades. This isn't just some rinky-dink
land investment like the one dredged up by right-wing enemies to haunt the Clinton
White House--but rather it has the makings of the greatest presidential scandal
since the Teapot Dome.
The Bush administration has a long and intimate relationship with Enron, whose
much-discredited chairman, Kenneth L. Lay, was a primary financial backer of
George W. Bush's rise to the presidency.
It was Enron that provided the model for the administration's trickle-down attempt
to revive an economy that's been in steep decline during Bush's tenure. That
model gives the fat-cat corporate hotshots everything they want in return for
bankrolling political campaigns. Not to worry about the rest of us because,
hey, what's good for Enron is good for America. That it hasn't been is now painfully
clear.
What did Enron get in return for its contributions? It got its way on deregulation,
for one thing. Remember when the administration refused to assist California
and other states during the energy crisis, and consumers paid the steep price?
So greedy was Enron that it locked its own workers into a pension plan based
on inflated company stock values and suspect hidden partnerships, while the
top leadership led by Lay made out like bandits.
Bush should be called as a witness in the congressional hearings scheduled to
unravel this mess. One thing that should come up in the hearings is then-Gov.
Bush's October 1997 telephone call on behalf of Lay to then-Pennsylvania Gov.
Tom Ridge to help Enron crack into the tightly regulated Pennsylvania electricity
market.
"I called George W. to kind of tell him what was going on," Lay told the New
York Times about the 1997 phone call, "and I said that it would be very helpful
to Enron, which is obviously a large company in the state of Texas, if he could
just call the governor [of Pennsylvania] and tell him [Enron]
is a serious company, this is a professional company, a good company."
Since we now know Enron lacked those virtues, it's clear Bush was used to sell
a bill of goods to the unsuspecting Pennsylvania folks.
That Lay was instrumental in Bush's rise to the presidency is indisputable.
Since 1993, Lay and top Enron executives donated nearly $2 million to Bush.
Lay also personally donated $326,000 in soft money to the Republican Party in
the three years prior to Bush's presidential bid, and he was one of the Republican
"pioneers" who raised $100,000 in smaller contributions for Bush. Lay's wife
donated $100,000 for inauguration festivities.
As governor, Bush did what Enron wanted, cutting taxes and deregulating utilities.
The deregulation ideology, which George W. long had adopted as gospel, allowed
dubious bookkeeping and other acts of chicanery that shocked Wall Street and
drove a $60-billion company, seventh on the Fortune 500 list, into bankruptcy.
This emerging scandal makes Whitewater seem puny in comparison; clearly there
ought to be at least as aggressive a congressional inquiry into the connection
between the Bush administration and the Enron debacle. Facts must be revealed,
beginning with the content of Lay's private meeting with Vice President Dick
Cheney to create the administration's energy policy.
What was Lay's role in the sudden replacement of Curtis Hebert Jr. as Federal
Energy Regulatory Commission chairman? As the New York Times reported, Hebert
"had barely settled into his new job this year when he had an unsettling telephone
conversation with Kenneth L. Lay, [in which Lay] prodded him to back
... a faster pace in opening up access to the electricity transmission grid
to companies like Enron." Lay admits making the call but in an unctuous defense
of his influence peddling said, "The final decision on [Hebert's job]
was going to be the president's, certainly not ours." Soon after, Hebert was
replaced by Texan Pat Wood, who was favored by Lay.
Other questions: Was there any conflict of interest in the roles played by key
Bush aides? Political advisor Karl Rove owned as much as $250,000 in Enron stock.
And economic advisor Larry Lindsay and Trade Representative Robert B. Zoellick
went straight from Enron's payroll to their federal jobs.
There are other Enron alum in the administration, including Army Secretary Thomas
White Jr., who, as an Enron executive, held stock and options totaling $50 million
to $100 million.
We have a right to know whether the Enron alums in the administration were tipped
off in time to bail out with profit the way Lay and the other Enron top execs
did, while their workers and stockholders--and eventually U.S. taxpayers--are
being left holding the suddenly empty bag.
*
Robert Scheer writes a syndicated column.