ex-CIA McGovern (VIPS): Deceived into War

Deceived into War -Ordering Powell with Rice

When FOX TV asked me to present my views Sunday on the ongoing quest for weapons of mass destruction in Iraq, the first thing the anchor asked was why I should care about the phantom wmds when the vast majority of Americans don't.

I responded, somewhat indecorously, that this was largely the fault of FOX news and other media that have kept Americans malnourished on small issues like why our country launched a "preemptive" war.

I was dyspeptic on Sunday after watching Condoleezza Rice and Colin Powell blow still more smoke at these key issues and disparage those with altogether legitimate questions.

Powell said it was "nonsense" to brand as "bogus" the intelligence adduced to justify making war on Iraq. But, sadly, "bogus" is precisely the correct word to apply to the key piece of "evidence" used to deceive our representatives and senators into voting to give President Bush permission to launch an unprovoked war on Iraq.

However strong a word, "bogus" pales in comparison with the seven-letter F-word to which Powell and Rice showed themselves allergic: F for forgery.

Yes, forgery. Had FOX and other news outlets adequately reported on what both Powell had already conceded was a forgery, the American people might have a better appreciation as to why they should care.

I refer to the bogus story that Iraq was attempting to acquire uranium from Niger to develop nuclear weapons. Those who followed developments at the UN have known since February that that story was based on a crude forgery. What is little known is that the Bush administration knew it was bogus a full year earlier. (Those who find themselves wondering why Powell and Rice have conceded the point need only to remember that the UN now has the forged documents.)

To his credit, early last year Vice President Dick Cheney sent to Niger a former US ambassador in Africa to investigate the story. The latter brought back word that the documents were not authentic. But this did not prevent senior administration officials from using them in the critical run-up to Congress' vote to give the president the authority to make war.

Indeed, President Bush included the forged "evidence" in his state-of-the-union address on January 28-something Dr. Rice, when asked about it by George Stephanopoulos on Sunday, was at a loss to explain satisfactorily. Now "senior administration officials" are telling gullible reporters that Cheney was never informed of the outcome of the investigation he ordered. I'm not making this up.

Recent press reports of a Defense Intelligence Agency study of Sept. 2002 that found "no definitive, reliable information" that Iraq was producing or stockpiling chemical or biological weapons has helped me connect the dots, so to speak.

Last fall's full-court press to get Congress to vote for war required proof that Iraq posed a clear and present danger. As Bush's strategists reviewed the bidding, it became painfully clear that allegations of a confirmed chemical and biological threat would run too great a risk of being undermined by uncooperative analysts in the DIA.

At that point the White House decided to present evidence raising the specter of nuclear weapons in the hands of Saddam Hussein and play up the danger of a "mushroom cloud." Former UN nuclear inspector David Albright said Sunday that he was "deeply troubled by the selective use of information to basically scare people. People are scared by nuclear weapons. And it's a button."

But where was the evidence? It is now clear that the only thing available at that time was the so-called argument from aluminum tubes. There had been reports of Iraq trying to procure them from abroad, and those eager to please the White House offered instant "analysis" that the tubes were for Iraq's "nuclear program." Thus, Dr. Rice on Sept. 8, 2002 told Wolf Blitzer that "Saddam Hussein is actively pursuing a nuclear weapon. We do know that there have been shipments into Iraq of aluminum tubes that really are only suited to nuclear weapons programs."

But when the engineers and scientists at US nuclear labs were consulted, their virtually unanimous conclusion was that the tubes were not suitable for a nuclear application. So that line of argument turned out to be as weak as the chemical and biological weapons evidence about which DIA analysts were so suspicious.

What was left? Someone remembered the forged correspondence between Iraq and Niger, decided that it could be used to win the vote in Congress, to win the war in Iraq, and in the afterglow of victory, no one would care that the evidence was bogus.

It worked.

Small wonder that Rep. Henry Waxman (D, CA), in a March 17 letter to the president, expressed outrage at having been deceived into voting for war, since "the evidence cited regarding Iraq's efforts to obtain nuclear weapons is a hoax."

Ray McGovern, a CIA analyst for 27 years, is now on the Steering Group of Veteran Intelligence Professionals for Sanity. His day job is co-director of the Servant Leadership School, an inner-city outreach ministry in Washington, DC.

Check out other Counterpunch Top Stories of this week:

Chris Floyd Bush Family Lies About Iraq and Nazi Germany

Wayne Madsen Weaponsgate

Jason Leopold Bush White House Silenced Critics of Iraq WMD

More on Ray McGovern

Ray McGovern: CIA Officer on the Agency's Days of Shame
... By RAY McGOVERN Former CIA analyst. ... Ray McGovern was a CIA analyst for 27 years and
is on the Steering Group of Veteran Intelligence Professionals for Sanity. ...
www.counterpunch.org/mcgovern02132003.html - 19k - Cached - Similar pages

Ray McGovern: Colin Powell's Blurry Pictures
... It is?". by RAY McGOVERN Former CIA analyst. ... And so do we all. Ray McGovern
worked as an all-source analyst at CIA for 27 years. He is ...
www.counterpunch.org/mcgovern02262003.html - 24k - Cached - Similar pages
[ More results from www.counterpunch.org ]

AlterNet: AlterNet: Also by Ray McGovern
... Stories by Ray McGovern. Memo to the President An ad-hoc group of veteran
CIA analysts gives the president a much-needed intelligence briefing. ...
www.alternet.org/alsoby.html?StoryID=15127 - 13k - Cached - Similar pages

WebActive: Pacifica's Peacewatch
... Story: RAY MCGOVERN OF VETERANS INTELLIGENCE PROFESSIONALS FOR SANITY ANALYZES
PRIVATE CONVERSATION BETWEEN POWELL AND STRAW REGARDING IRAQ'S WMDS. ...
www.webactive.com/pacifica/peacewatch/ peace20030603.html - 11k - Cached - Similar pages

WebActive: Pacifica's Peacewatch
... says it's probably 'a lie'. Today Peacewatch spoke with Ray McGovern,
who is a former All Sources CIA agent. Ray McGovern, who is a ...
www.webactive.com/pacifica/peacewatch/ peace20030421.html - 10k - Cached - Similar pages
[ More results from www.webactive.com ]

The Miami Herald | 01/27/2003 | Why fight Iraq? For Dad, oil, ...
... By RAY McGOVERN ... Ray McGovern, a former Army intelligence officer, co-directs the
Servant Leadership School, an inner-city outreach ministry in Washington, DC. ...
www.miami.com/mld/miamiherald/news/opinion/5037753.htm - 37k - Cached - Similar pages

Signs of attacks well-known
Posted on Mon, Jun. 03, 2002, RAY MCGOVERN Signs of attacks well-known
No one wants to believe that the attacks of Sept. 11 could ...
www.miami.com/mld/miami/3387673.htm?template=contentModules/ printstory.jsp - 8k - Cached - Similar pages
[ More results from www.miami.com ]

San Francisco Examiner
... BY RAY MCGOVERN Special to The Examiner. ... Ray McGovern served as an Army infantry
and intelligence officer in 1962-64 and then as a CIA analyst until 1990. ...
www.examiner.com/opinion/ default.jsp?story=op.mcgovern.0106w - 28k - Cached - Similar pages

Head of Senate panel: open hearings on WMD possible
San Francisco Chronicle, CA - 1 hour ago
... weapons of mass destruction have not been found in Iraq and accusations that some
evidence ... it instead favored the routine oversight formula for hearings ...

Answers needed on Iraq decision
Fort Worth Star Telegram, TX - 10 hours ago
... and international television cameras to present the evidence ... There has been a call
for congressional hearings to ... nature and quality of the intelligence in Iraq ...
       Skip witch hunt - Arizona Republic
       The Dog Ate My WMD - TomPaine.com

British MPs probe Iraq war decision
Queensland Sunday Mail, Australia - 20 hours ago
... Foreign Affairs Committee hearings are normally held in ... credibility of the president
who prosecuted the Iraq ... Anderson's committee plans to take oral evidence ...

If Bush Is Lying, He's Not the First
Washington Post - 5 hours ago
... so far have resisted the Democrats' call for public hearings into whether the intelligence
on Iraq ... some analysts claim was set up to find the evidence ...
       CIA expose new lie in Blair's Iraq dossier - Khilafah.com
       White House was warned of dubious intelligence used in speech, ...  - Miami Herald

Transcript: Senator Jane Harmon on Fox News Sunday
FOX News - 2 hours ago
... that President Bush's team might have doctored evidence ... be a prerequisite for members
participating in hearings to ... as the crossed the berm from Kuwait into Iraq ...

Weapons hunt demands patient call for accountability
Aberdeen American News, SD - 11 hours ago
... Indeed, we'll probably soon see congressional hearings ... from its previously unequivocal
claim that Iraq ... the Gallup Organization that only conclusive evidence of ...

Our Lives and Liberty Turn on Moussaoui
Antiwar.com, CA - 15 hours ago
... to find weapons of mass destruction in Iraq ... not above knowingly, intentionally, and
deliberately falsifying evidence ... Appeals hearing as well as various hearings ...

Pentagon denies it cooked Iraq evidence
Minneapolis Star Tribune, MN - Jun 4, 2003
... signed a petition demanding that Blair publish his evidence ... Chairman John Warner,
R-Va., said he planned hearings ... States would find the suspected weapons in Iraq ...

Congress should hold open hearings over Iraq weapons data
Gainesville Times, GA - Jun 12, 2003
... That's why thorough and open hearings are essential ... our staunchest allies in the military
action in Iraq ... Many in Britain also believe that the evidence for going ...

Closed hearings are planned on US reports of Iraqi arms
Boston Globe, MA - Jun 12, 2003
... 'Hearings ... T. Meehan, a Lowell Democrat who last year voted to allow force against
Iraq ... to color that intelligence in a way to make it appear that the evidence ...