|
We have an uphill task convincing people that we are normal people too. Because in Britain there is a deeply rooted fear and hatred of Islam that only needed an excuse like September 11th to bring it out into the open. Since then, we’ve seen the sickening racial prejudices against our worldwide community re-emerging with a vengeance.
It was when I heard the magic words “Islamic extremist” on September 11th that I prayed for some of our self-appointed leaders and organizations to take the initiative and counter the inevitable anti-Muslim propaganda that was to follow. It was exactly at this moment that we needed to be primed for the media, with military precision.
It wasn’t so. ITN ran with the story, as did the BBC and all the major channels. Soon we were horrified to see members of the extremist Al-Muhajiroun being interviewed as typical Muslims. The papers had a field day with such offerings like the Daily Mail’s “Fanatics with a death wish: I was born in Britain but I am a Muslim first” and “This fanaticism that we in the West can never understand.” It even had a cartoon of a Muslim holding a Death To America placard, titled “Parasite.”
On our TV screens we saw Muslim young men burning American flags, Palestinians rejoicing and pictures of women in full hijab with their children holding up pictures of Bin Laden.
The story about young Muslims going to fight with the Taliban have prompted even the most liberal of our press, like the Independent, to argue for removal of British Citizenship from these people. Even the relatively liberal boards on the BBC website overlook this sanction for Irish terrorists waging a war against the British government, or for young British Jews who serve in the Israeli Army, presumably on the basis that the Irish and Jews aren’t “foreign” enough.
But Muslims must always be tested for their loyalty. So we can have Tony Parsons from the Mirror openly telling British Muslims who don’t love their country to simply “leave.” And according to the Telegraph, we may be traitors but it’s all the fault of the liberal elite who pampered us too much. Anti-Muslim racism, like anti-Semitism before it, is now so fashionable that people like Richard Littlejohn of the Sun, and also a BBC Radio 5 presenter, could openly write a poisonous column defending revenge against the Afghans because they meant less to “us” than Americans did. “Us” meaning anyone, including Muslims, who disagreed with Littlejohn.
It is clear that the media has been seeking out those who speak with the loudest voices in order to make a good story. They are in business to sell news after all. And Islam, like anything else, shouldn’t be exempt from valid criticism. But valid criticism is very different from a constant running down of a religious belief. The motives of some media outlets are highly suspect and sinister.
On the top of the list has to be the top selling Telegraph, owned by the recently knighted Zionist Conrad Black, which has engaged in a tirade of abuse against Islam parading as concern for “moderate” Muslims and Israel. Seemingly innocuous commentators, like the fundamentalist Christian Patrick Sukhdeo with an agenda of his own, regularly denounce Islam as a “religion that sanctions all forms of violence.”
The American Daniel Pipes, a prolific Muslim hater, has called for racial profiling, the closure of Muslim Internet sites, the isolation of the Muslim Council of Britain, and accused the BBC of being a Muslim apologist. Barbara Amiel, Conrad’s own wife, kicked in with her own invective under the excuse of protecting Islam against fundamentalists. The letter sections have such enlightened views as the one which called for the execution of British Muslims who fight with the Taliban. These are just a few examples.
But we cannot point fingers and always blame the media because we’ve also allowed the media to get away with this type of stereotyping for far too long. I do not blame Al-Muhajiroun for getting so much coverage any more than I blame the Zionist spin-doctors who have been so successful in promoting Israel and trashing the Palestinians. The media is out there to be won and the people who get to it and use it will be the ones who win, and their enemies will be the losers. Pointing fingers at the futility of it all doesn’t get us anywhere. We should remember that a person who points a finger at someone else will always be pointing two fingers back at himself.
Against all this misrepresentation, cynicism and self-resignation is hope. For reasons more to do with keeping the Muslim “coalition” together than anything else, Tony Blair and George Bush have made it pretty clear to everyone that Islam was not to blame for what happened in America. And for the first time in its history, the Sun has followed the same line, though undoubtedly after taking “advice” from Blair’s advisers.
In terms of sales, the biggest winners have been those who share Muslim views and have taken a critical line against the “war,” like the Guardian and Independent. The Mirror learned that its circulation increased by millions after challenging the status quo and even published a highly critical anti-war article on its front page.
Muslims are at last starting to take the initiative with the media. We are now seeing young and articulate Muslims on our screens on a more regular basis. People like the journalist Faisal Bodi who can challenge and debate with a confidence that we would never expect from the older generation. Also, the BBC has the largest share of British viewing figures and it appears to have a more balanced line than other outlets. It even ran the risk of censure after it screened a controversial Question Time program on September 13th which had an audience including Muslims and others who were highly critical of American policy.
Even so, we have a long way to go before we can make a convincing case for Islam. But Tony Blair knows the media war is far from over. He has failed to win over the hearts and minds of the overwhelming majority of Muslims in Britain alone, never mind those who were always hostile to British foreign policy in other countries.
Still, it will not stop the American administration taking its “war” to places like Iraq. As Muslims we must change the hearts and minds of public opinion and turn them against this folly. We have the power and the resources and if we don’t do it, then why should we expect others to?
Bilal Patel is a British Muslim who argues for Muslims to be more pro-active in the media if they are to avoid the damaging stereotyping which leads to conflict. He runs the Media Watch site www.HonestReports.com
You can contact him at info@HonestReports.com for more information on media activism.
|